Excalibur Guard
Home Workshop Tool Reviews Woodworking Articles Projects

 

Excalibur Overhead Guard EXBC
Excalibur by Sommerville I bought the Excalibur a month or so after I bought the Unisaw in February.  At $389 it's fairly expensive.  However, there were enough people on the woodworking boards who had lost fingers, parts of fingers, or partial use of their hands that I decided to buy some safety equipment before I needed it.

Installing the guard was a far greater effort than I expected it to be.  It took me about 30 hours to get everything together.  A lot of that time was spent shopping for parts.  

The first issue I ran into was the fact that it's designed for a thicker extension table.  (I haven't tried it but it's my understanding that the biesemeyer extension table will work without modification.)  Because the holes in the right angle metal didn't line up with a 3/4" table I have to buy a piece of 1" square aluminum at Home Depot, drill some holes in it, and bolt that to the extension table.  Viola!  Now I have a thicker table.

The next issue was keeping the saw mobile.  The normal way to install the guard has a support leg reaching all the way to the ground.  To get around this I measured the width of the mobile base frame and attached the angle iron to the wooden platform.  Next, I slid the platform's angle iron over the mobile base frame, drilled a few holes and bolted it in place.

When that was done I attached the main arm to the vertical portion of the unit and put the support leg in place.  With the leg where I needed it to be I secured it in place with small wooded strips.

The support leg is supposed to be mounted to the underside of the table with two metal bars that they provide.  You can see them here.  However, because of the shelf that came with my Unisaw the arms could not be installed.  The good news is that with the mobile platform's wooden strips holding it in place I don't need them.

In usage, it works very well.  The dust collection is nearly flawless.  I ran 6" pipe which happens to have almost exactly twice the flow of a 4" pipe.  Knowing that, I have a 6x4x4 reducing Y and I run 4" hose to the guard and another 4" hose to the Unisaw.

While I still list sliding it out of the way in my "bad" column I've developed a bit more skill at it.  I can usually slide it right where I want it the first time.  When making very narrow rips you would need to slide it off center so that they fence can get closer to the blade.  You need to slide it totally out of the way when cutting box joints, etc.

Raising and lowering it is a pleasure.  I have it set to provide a good amount of resistance so that it stays in place even if the wood tried to lift.  However, I still find raising and lowering it to be an easy task.  In short, the tension can be nicely "dialed in".

 


Unisaw (before DC was installed)

The Good:
bullet

While I bought it to save my fingers I love it for it's dust collection.  Cabinet saws in general have fair dust collection but having the ability to suck from the top and the bottom is a wonderful thing.

bullet

It's big, heavy, and strong.  It will hold a 4' piece of plywood in place while it hangs off the edge.  This "extra hand" is useful from time to time.

bullet

I love the look of it.

bullet

It's one of the few guards that doesn't attach to the back of the saw.  I needed that because of my outfeed table.

bullet

It stays where I put it because the tension on the guard is easily "dialed in".

The Bad:

bullet

Sliding it out of the way takes more effort than I would consider to be "perfect".  I don't oil it because I worry it would get too slippery.

bullet

Installing it was a pain.

bullet

At $389 it's fairly expensive for something you hope you never need.  I bet there are a lot of people out there that want a guard but it never makes it to the top of their buying list because of the price.

Conclusion:

This was a good buy.  I also considered the Brett Guard but in the end the Excalibur won out. I liked the way it mounted and the flexibility of choosing my own splitter.  It's almost worth the price for the fantastic dust collection.  However, it's core duty of making me aware of where the blade is and keeping my fingers away from it is the reason that I'd recommend it or something like it.

Jan 2004 Update :  I wrote this in a recent woodnet post and I thought it might add value to my review.

Safety
Has it saved me? I don't think so. What it has done is it has made me very aware of the danger zone. I have a big yellow block hanging in the area that my hands are not supposed to enter. I don't recall bumping my hands into it but I like having it there and I feel "naked/vulnerable" when I can't use the guard.

Dust

This is a big deal to me. Inhaling dust is a lot like smoking cigarettes. Some people are bothered in just a few months while others go years without a problem at all. I was bothered after a few months. I'm not sure if I'm lucky that I had to get serious about dust collection before the dust caused cancer, emphysema, or asthma, or maybe I'm unlucky that I was impacted so quickly. Anyway, enough digressing.

Sucking from underneath the blade isn't a good way to catch the dust. A lot of the dust is thrown above the blade straight at the user. Only an overhead guard can make a table saw any good at catching dust. If you don't have an overhead guard you don't know what you're missing.

Vision

Yeah, you can't see the action as well. It has clear plastic that you can see through but mine is a bit junked up with dust and some burnt sugar from ripping hard maple. I could clean it again but to tell you the truth, I only care to see that the blade is higher than the stock is thick. Everything else would be something other than making sure I'm against the fence properly. I can see all that I care to see. Honestly, that's not me rationalizing. I don't care for Norm's view. I don't look at the blade.

Fine Woodworking Review

 

© Copyright 2003-2005 Vanguard

Feedback